[Bug] Comment editing non-functional

Feedback & Bugs
#1

When submitting an edited comment in the solutions pages, nothing happens: i.e. the comment remains open in “editable” mode, the submit/cancel buttons remain active.

The console logs this (vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6):

TypeError: k.comment.edit is not a function
    at o.k.submitEdit (https://www.codingame.com/codingame.ecadd589.js:6:20680)
    at f.fn (https://www.codingame.com/codingame.ecadd589.js:6:20016)
    at f.doAction (https://www.codingame.com/codingame.ecadd589.js:11:24710)
    at fn (eval at compile (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:8:13781), <anonymous>:4:303)
    at b (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:18903)
    at e (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:9:2109)
    at o.$eval (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:28979)
    at o.$apply (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:29212)
    at HTMLButtonElement.<anonymous> (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:9:2161)
    at HTMLButtonElement.dispatch (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:2:14465)
    at HTMLButtonElement.q.handle (https://www.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:2:11242) undefined
#2

We cannot reproduce here, do you have more details?
Which browser? which puzzle? which solution?

Keep coding

#3

Dunno how to link to comments more specifically, but it’s the “20 sept. 2016 14:06:26” one on https://www.codingame.com/training/community/near-palindromes/solution?id=4433856

Browser currently is Chrome 53.0.2785.116 m on Win7.

It reproduces after a big refresh or a fresh login in private mode. It also reproduces in Firefox.

#4

And that happens only on this specific comment? Is there something particular on it? (we can’t access it easily, we’d need to solve the puzzle in perl too :P)

#5

It’s the only one I have that’s in such dire need of editing :slight_smile:
I’ve tried on this one https://www.codingame.com/training/easy/onboarding/solution?id=1815013 and it seems to edit just fine. Maybe only for comments old enough?

I’ve tried on this older comment here https://www.codingame.com/contributions/view/3883d8d5b068b603f12fab47f003f094392 and it worked.

This is getting confusing.

#6

Reproduced the same symptoms on a slightly different scenario while attempting to post an answer to Zexion’s comment here: https://www.codingame.com/contributions/view/46851c0fe09e7e9725ad1f768d091234bf9
(should be publicly available even if you haven’t solved it in Perl)

The console log is very slightly different (vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6):

TypeError: Cannot read property 'modeHourOfCode' of undefined
    at Object.r [as requireLogin] (https://static.codingame.com/codingame.d27988c3.js:14:21288)
    at Object.submitComment (https://static.codingame.com/codingame.d27988c3.js:12:21205)
    at i.submitResponse (https://static.codingame.com/codingame.d27988c3.js:12:19996)
    at o.g.submit (https://static.codingame.com/codingame.d27988c3.js:6:24702)
    at fn (eval at compile (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:8:13781), <anonymous>:4:209)
    at b (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:18903)
    at e (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:9:2109)
    at o.$eval (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:28979)
    at o.$apply (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:6:29212)
    at HTMLButtonElement.<anonymous> (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:9:2161)
    at HTMLButtonElement.dispatch (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:2:14465)
    at HTMLButtonElement.q.handle (https://static.codingame.com/vendors.5b9efc3f.js:2:11242) undefined

It reproduces across the browsers I’ve got installed here.

#7

Fixed in dev, waiting merge.

#8

That was fast!