Here are some enhancements that I thought of when I contribute/help contribution.
I also found this 1-year-old topic which deals with contribution sorting.
This other 1-year-old topic deals with interactive puzzles.
For a contributor:
- When writing a draft, the formatting is not applied. You have to submit it as non-draft before you see the formating.
- It's strange to have the button to test it in an IDE only on edition mode (well, it can make sense, but it's different from when the puzzle is submitted).
- The contribution guidelines are outdated.
- Monospace strings leads to a block. It is not possible to have it inlined.
- Allow more than 1000 characters in the output. (The limit is 10000 for the input)
- Allow URLs (but I understand it may be dangerous)
- For the stub generator:
- Allow writing constants (numbers, texts, maybe maps or lists)
- (I found something that made sense but was not accepted, but I can't find it anymore)
For a moderator:
- Pending puzzles list page:
- See if you have already approved (green ✓) or refused (red ✗) a puzzle so that you know you don't need to come back.
- Have a mark telling how much approvals/refusals have been done.
- Separate CoC from CP puzzles.
In a puzzle page:
- Have a better indication of the type of the puzzle. The only way currently is a faint gray text over a gray background, at the top, hidden as soon as you descend in the comments, an the section "Game mode" which is present or not.
In a puzzle IDE:
- If it is a CoC, allow switching to "Reverse" mode. Activating the Test cases in a modal window is not easy.
- It would be good to test the tests first, then the validators. This would allow testing if a validator covers something the test cases don't.
Yeah, I know it's Christmas soon